Tucked away in Holmes Beach, The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe was a cherished local gem that felt like a home away from home. It was the kind of place you'd pop into for a truly phenomenal coffee and a breakfast sandwich so hearty it would keep you going all day. While the handcrafted cheesecakes, made from a 40-year-old family recipe, were the main event, their gourmet sandwiches and friendly atmosphere made it a beloved spot on the island that is dearly missed.